← Notes

Favilla guide · Bitcoin · November 2026

Random-looking isn’t random

A seed made from guessable randomness looks exactly like a good one. Here is what you can check, what you can't, and how to take the device out of the question.

In July 2026, Coinkite warned that some Coldcard firmware could make wallet keys that were easier for attackers to guess, and told affected users to create a new wallet and move their bitcoin. The seeds looked perfectly random. That is the uncomfortable part.

What you can't check

You can't tell by looking. Twelve or twenty-four words look the same whether they came from good randomness or from a counter.

Tests can't tell either. We ran every statistical test we had on our own bench data, and noted that the generator in the Coldcard case would have passed them comfortably. Tests catch a broken source. They can't prove a source was unpredictable. Our measurements are here.

What you can do: bring your own randomness

The one check that doesn't depend on trusting the device is to supply the randomness yourself and confirm the device used it.

Seed lengthSix-sided dice rollsRandomness
12 words50 rollsabout 129 bits
24 words99 rollsabout 256 bits
  1. Use real dice. Casino dice are the most even; ordinary dice work too. Roll them yourself, somewhere private, and write the results down.
  2. Use a wallet that documents its method. It should say exactly how rolls become words, and add nothing of its own when you use dice.
  3. Check it offline. On a computer that isn't connected to anything, repeat the wallet's published method with your rolls and confirm you get the same words. Then wipe that computer's copy.

Dice protect you from a bad random chip and from bad firmware alike, because the device never chooses the seed.

If your seed came from a device with a known flaw

Follow the maker's advice. The safe pattern is the one Coinkite gave: make a new wallet with good randomness, then send your coins to it. A strong BIP-39 passphrase adds a secret an attacker also has to guess, but don't rely on it to rescue a seed you know is weak.

How the Favilla KEY handles it

At setup you choose. Dice: roll 50 or 99 times, and the KEY turns your rolls into words with a published function, mixing in nothing from the device. You can repeat it offline and confirm the words. Two chips: the KEY reads one grid of randomness from the secure element and one from the camera, shows you both, and combines them, so a flaw in either chip alone isn't enough. You can redo that arithmetic on the seed check page.

The honest limit: the two-chip path protects you from a bad chip, not from bad firmware on the main processor that combines them. Only dice remove that trust too.

The Favilla KEY is not on sale yet. Read the FAQ or get early access →